Advanced Search



Lot #
Gallery View
Price Grid
Recent Bids spacer

LOT 1201:  1884 Providence (vs. Buffalo) National League Scorecard with "Old Hoss" Radbourn on the Cover



CURRENT BID:  $1,700.00

Start:  4/13/2011 1:15:00 PM EST 

End:  5/8/2011 4:15:00 AM EST

Auction is closed

  STARTING BID:  $500.00

BID COUNT:  13 (Bid History)

Add to Watchlist
Email Robert Edward Auctions

Extremely rare 1884 Providence fold-over scorecard featuring an illustration of Hall of Fame pitcher Charles "Old Hoss" Radbourn on the cover. Providence player portraits. Interestingly, Radbourn's printed name below his image is misspelled "Radburn" by the publisher (The Strobridge Lith Co., of Cincinnati, Ohio). This is only the second 1884 Providence scorecard featuring Radbourn on the cover that we have ever seen. The year of this program is of all the greater note in that Radbourn enjoyed the greatest season of his career in 1884 as he won a Major League record 59 games, against only 12 losses, in leading the Providence Grays to the National League pennant. He then went on to win all three games against the American Association champion New York Metropolitans in the first-ever World Series that fall. (The inaugural World Series was only a three-game series.) Radbourn, in addition to being one of the greatest pitchers of his era, was, according to the Providence Journal-Bulletin , "erratic, capricious, and ill-tempered." Although he won a league-high 48 games in 1883, no one could have predicted his prodigious accomplishment the following year, especially after he was suspended by the club at midseason for reported "improper conduct." (One report said that following a dropped third strike by his catcher, Radbourn cursed him and fired a baseball at his forehead so hard that it knocked him out.) It was only a stroke of fate that brought him back to the fold. Right after his suspension, the team's only other pitcher, Bill Sweeney, jumped the club, leaving Providence in an uncomfortable bind. Radbourn, realizing the team had no choice but to reinstate him, not only negotiated a bonus for his return, but was also granted the right to become a free agent at season's end. In return, he agreed to pitch every remaining game, which he nearly did (the team gave him a few breaks by pitching position players in some games). This particular program, issued for a game against Buffalo, is not scored but was probably a good one, as it featured a pitching match up between two of the greatest pitchers of the era, Rabourn and Pud Galvin. The preprinted lineups include Radbourn, Hines, Start, Bassett, and Carroll for Providence, and O'Rourke, Brouthers, Richardson, and Galvin for Buffalo. The scorecard (3.75 x 6 inches) displays a very slight separation along both the top and bottom of the spine; it is otherwise in Excellent condition overall. The only other 1884 Providence program featuring Radbourn on the cover that we have seen (scored, but in lesser condition) appeared as Lot 57 in Robert Edward Auctions' May 2010 auction, where it realized a final sale price of $3,231. This is an incredible Radbourn item: It is incredibly rare, naturally ideal for display, of great note for featuring a portrait of Radbourn, and dating from his most historic season. Reserve $500. Estimate $1,000/$2,000+.
Click on a thumbnail image above to display a larger image below.

Lot Image
CURRENT BID: $1,700.00
NEXT BID: $1,800.00
(if autobid is on)
You need to login to place a bid. Enter your bidder number and password below and we will bring you right back to this page.

Bidder Number:
Forgot Bidder Number?
Forgot Password?

1. Register to bid - if you haven't already. It's free!

2. Login - if you haven't already. We'll bring you right back to this page.

3. Select your bid amount.

4. Preview your bid.

5. Submit your final bid!

If you have questions, contact Robert Edward Auctions before you bid.